BLOG: From African American Apocalyptic Fiction to Children’s Rights in the Digital Environment, by Colin Gibson

My day job is writing a doctoral thesis on futures in African American apocalyptic fiction, so it was surprising to be asked by Dr. Gerison Landsown to review international documents on children’s rights and the digital environment. The project was to help the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child develop a new standard known as a General Comment. Given that doctoral work is mostly a lone pursuit that involves having lots of tabs open on my laptop and books strewn around my desk covered in Post-it notes, I leapt at the idea of doing something that could have a very real global impact.

Dr. Lansdown was working with the 5Rights Foundation, which aims to articulate the existing rights of children and young people in the digital world, and Professors Sonia Livingstone from the London School of Economics and Amanda Third from Western Sydney University. The topic was fascinating. It wasn’t something I’d given serious thought to before; the internet often seems like a free-for-all, a kind of digital Wild West. Yet, of course, it’s anything but, especially for children. While the potential for creativity and connection online is huge, the internet is increasingly a place where commercial and political interests dominate what is possible and what is not. We live in a world that worries incessantly about children’s safety online, but often fails to think beyond this and ask how we can make the digital environment – impossible to separate from the ‘real’ world – a better space for children.

So, my role was to see where the UN had considered children’s rights in the digital environment. This involved trawling through reports, resolutions, research, official observations, existing standards, and so much more. I was warned before I started that the dominant theme was going to be child protection, specifically from sexual exploitation, and this proved to be the case. Of course, this is unarguably of crucial importance; if children are not safe, they cannot enjoy the full range of rights outlined in the CRC. But as 5Rights Foundation emphasises, it’s not just about avoiding danger, children have the potential to benefit tremendously from going online. Children need to be empowered as rights-holders to shape the digital environment themselves, to participate in it as active citizens, to be creative and make connections with their peers. Their best interests and evolving capacities need to be front and centre in both legislation and design. In short, children must be able to exercise their full range of their rights online.  

More recent UN documentation has increasingly begun to reflect this attitude. UNICEF, in particular, have published a range of reports that insist on a more holistic approach to children’s rights in the digital environment. The Committee on the Rights of the Child’s Day of General Discussion in 2014 also helped to set the UN agenda for a more expansive approach. But there nevertheless remains a paucity of information on issues such as children’s privacy – how do we consider children’s place in a commercial model that relies on data collection, and how can the child’s right to privacy be balanced against their right to freedom of expression? How can protection rights be fully realised without impinging on their right to participate or to play?  These questions – and many more - are inconclusively and incompletely addressed. Having done the research, I very much hope it proves as useful as it has been interesting and rewarding to carry out. But I have to admit I’m not envious of those who have to provide the answers! It’s back to the apocalypse for me.

5Rights Foundation makes case for children's rights at IGF, Berlin 2019

Read More

5Rights Foundation leads joint UK letter to FTC on COPPA Rule Review

Read More

UNCRC General Comment expert consultation takes place in London

Read More

Broadband Commission calls for meaningful universal connectivity to drive global development

Read More

100+ brilliant women in AI making technology work for, and with, society

Read More

5Rights joins Peace Day pledge against Cyber Violence

Read More

Let’s make it easy for online services to protect children’s data

Read More

BLOG: From African American Apocalyptic Fiction to Children’s Rights in the Digital Environment, by Colin Gibson

Read More

5Rights YouGov poll: Parents' views on internet and child data protection regulation

Read More

The Age Appropriate Design Code: "A new deal between children and the tech sector"

Read More

5Rights welcomes Online Harms White Paper, calls for swifter legislation

Read More

Working with the Government of Rwanda and Police Scotland to support children online

Read More

House of Lords Select Committee on Communications Publish Report ‘Regulating in a Digital World’

Read More

UNCRC General Comment on children’s rights in relation to the digital environment

Read More

Council on Extended Intelligence Publish ‘The Case for Extended Intelligence’

Read More

UN High Level Panel on Digital Cooperation

Read More